What coverage gaps should I watch for when switching insurance companies?

People make mistakes by under-insuring their house, not adding water backup or jewelry coverage, or forgetting to add all the drivers in their household to the policy.

Key Takeaways

• Common gaps: under-insured dwelling, no water backup, unscheduled jewelry.
• Make sure every household driver is listed.

You’ve decided to switch carriers. The quote looks better, the agent seems sharp, and you’re ready to move. Then six months in, a tree comes down on the deck and you discover the new policy excluded something the old one covered, or didn’t catch the addition you finished last spring. That’s the failure mode of a fast switch — and it’s almost always preventable with a one-hour review before the new policy binds. The gaps we see most often are the same handful of issues, repeated across thousands of households.

The under-insured dwelling

This is the most common and the most expensive. A policy that was written eight years ago at a dwelling limit that made sense then is now sitting under today’s rebuild cost, sometimes by twenty or thirty percent. When the new policy quotes, it often inherits that old number — because that’s what the consumer thinks is correct. Recheck the dwelling against current local construction costs before binding the new policy, and we explain how to test it in how to tell if your coverage is outdated and having enough homeowners coverage.

Missing water and flood endorsements

Water backup. Sewer and drain. Sump pump. Flood. None of these are automatic — they’re elections. If the old policy had them and the new one doesn’t carry them forward, that’s a real gap. If the old policy didn’t have them either, this is the moment to add them rather than continue an oversight. Our explainer on flood and home insurance covers the difference between these coverages.

Unscheduled jewelry and high-value items

Standard home policies cap jewelry losses at around $1,500 per item or in total. A wedding ring, an inherited piece, or a watch can blow through that cap on a single loss. The fix is a scheduled-articles endorsement that lists the item by description and value. The same applies to:

  • Engagement and wedding rings
  • Inherited or antique jewelry
  • Luxury watches
  • Fine art and collectibles
  • Firearms beyond standard limits
  • Musical instruments
  • Cameras and high-end electronics used for business

When we move clients to a new carrier, we re-pull the schedule and update values to current appraisals — many appraisals are years out of date.

Missing drivers in the household

A 16-year-old who just got a license, a college student home for the summer, a spouse who joined the household — all of them need to be listed on the auto policy. Carriers can deny or reduce a claim if an unlisted household driver was at the wheel. This catches more switching households than any other auto issue.

Liability limits that don’t match an umbrella

If you carry an umbrella policy, the underlying home and auto need to meet the umbrella’s minimum liability requirements. Carriers occasionally adjust those minimums. A switch is a clean opportunity to make sure the underlying limits still satisfy the umbrella — we walk through this in whether to raise liability limits when switching.

How we close the gaps before binding

Our process is a one-page diff. We list every coverage and limit on the old policy in the left column, every coverage and limit on the proposed new policy in the right column, and any difference is flagged. We don’t bind until you’ve seen and signed off on the diff. That’s the same approach we describe in reviewing policies for gaps and overlaps and making sure the new policy matches your coverage. When you’re ready, request a personal insurance quote and we’ll run the diff for you.

Have more questions about our insurance?

Give us a call today and we can help.

Have more questions? Browse FAQs by type.

Local Mokena Insurance Agency
Always Here For You, Wherever You Are
Hicks Insurance Group provides home, auto, life, and commmercial insurance services throughout Illinois including Mokena, Joliet, Orland Park, Tinley Park, New Lenox, Frankfort, Chicago, Naperville, Oak Lawn, and Cicero as well as the counties of Will, Kendall, Grundy, and DuPage.
Still have questions?
No worries - we're here to help. Get the reassurance you need and contact us today.
© 2026 Hicks Insurance Group. All Rights Reserved.

Website Made By Aelieve Digital Marketing

Privacy Policy & Legal
Get Your Personal Insurance Quote
In need of anything from car insurance to rental insurance? We have you covered.
Get Your Commercial Insurance Quote
Ready to get started with your Commercial Insurance plan? You're in the right place.
Get Your Life
Insurance Quote
In need of anything from disability insurance to long-term care? We have you covered.
Get Your Personal Insurance Quote
In need of anything from car insurance to rental insurance? We have you covered.
Get Your Commercial Insurance Quote
Ready to get started with your Commercial Insurance plan? You're in the right place.
Get Your Life
Insurance Quote
In need of anything from disability insurance to long-term care? We have you covered.
Get Your Personal Insurance Quote
In need of anything from car insurance to rental insurance? We have you covered.
Get Your Commercial Insurance Quote
Ready to get started with your Commercial Insurance plan? You're in the right place.
Get Your Life
Insurance Quote
In need of anything from disability insurance to long-term care? We have you covered.
Get Your Personal Insurance Quote
In need of anything from car insurance to rental insurance? We have you covered.
Get Your Commercial Insurance Quote
Ready to get started with your Commercial Insurance plan? You're in the right place.
Get Your Life
Insurance Quote
In need of anything from disability insurance to long-term care? We have you covered.