Is it difficult to switch insurance agencies?

Once you’ve done a full review of your insurance and received your quotes, it’s very easy to change to a new agency. Documents are generally sent electronically via email, and you’re able to buy coverage within twenty-four hours.

Key Takeaways

• Switching is easy after a review and quotes.
• Paperwork is electronic — coverage can bind within 24 hours.

Picture this. A homeowner in the south suburbs gets a renewal notice with a premium jump that does not match any change in her household. She calls our office on a Tuesday morning, sends over her current declarations pages by lunch, and by Wednesday afternoon she has a bound policy with a different carrier and a refund coming from her old company. That is what a real-world agency switch looks like for most of our clients.

The mechanics are not complicated. The work is in the review beforehand and the document handling at the end. We handle the second part. You only need to be available for the first.

Why the process feels easier than people expect

People assume switching agencies means hours on the phone, faxing forms, and chasing down information from a previous agent. That picture is about a decade out of date. Documents now travel by secure email, e-signature platforms, and carrier portals. If your current agency has your declarations pages and billing statements ready, we can build accurate quotes from our carrier partners within a day or two.

The slower part is not paperwork. It is the conversation about coverage. We will not move you to a new carrier without first making sure the quotes we send actually match what you have today, plus any coverages you should have been carrying all along. That is where the value of working with an independent agency shows up.

What the typical switch timeline looks like

For most personal lines clients, the timeline runs like this. Day one, we collect your current dec pages and billing. Day two, we run quotes across multiple carriers and review them together. Day three or four, you sign electronically and your new policies bind. The old policy gets canceled on its expiration date so there is no lapse. The total time you personally spend is usually under an hour, spread across two short conversations.

What can slow things down

A few things can stretch the timeline, and it helps to know them up front.

  • Missing declarations pages from your current carrier
  • Open claims that are still being adjusted
  • Recent tickets or accidents that need underwriter review
  • A mortgage company that needs to be notified and verified
  • Specialty items like jewelry, boats, or rental properties that need separate scheduling

None of these are dealbreakers. They simply add a day or two while we gather information. If you are switching in the middle of a claim, we will usually recommend waiting until the claim settles before making the move.

What we handle versus what you handle

You handle three things. You answer questions about your household, your vehicles, and your property. You review the quotes with us. You sign the new applications. We handle the rest, including notifying your mortgage company about the new home policy and coordinating the effective dates so nothing overlaps incorrectly. If you want to know who cancels the old policy, the short answer is that you typically sign a cancellation form and we route it for you.

Ready to see what the process feels like for your household? Request a personal insurance quote and we will walk through the review together.

Why a careful review matters more than speed

Switching fast and switching well are not the same thing. A bad switch leaves you with a cheaper policy that is missing water backup, has inadequate liability limits, or fails to list one of the drivers in your household. We have rewritten policies where the previous agency missed two teen drivers and the policyholder did not realize it until a claim was denied. That is the kind of mistake a proper review catches.

Our preference is always to do a side-by-side review of your current policies before we present any quote. That review will sometimes tell us you should stay where you are because your existing coverage is solid. We would rather tell you that than move you for the sake of a sale.

What to expect after you switch

Once the new policies are bound, you will be assigned a single point of contact on our team. You will receive welcome emails from the new carrier with login details for billing and ID cards. Your mortgage company gets notified automatically for home policies. If your loan or lease company needs proof of new auto insurance, we send it directly.

If you want to start the review, reach out to our team or send your current dec pages through our bundle quote process. Most clients are surprised by how little of their own time the move actually takes.

Have more questions about our insurance?

Give us a call today and we can help.

Have more questions? Browse FAQs by type.

Local Mokena Insurance Agency
Always Here For You, Wherever You Are
Hicks Insurance Group provides home, auto, life, and commmercial insurance services throughout Illinois including Mokena, Joliet, Orland Park, Tinley Park, New Lenox, Frankfort, Chicago, Naperville, Oak Lawn, and Cicero as well as the counties of Will, Kendall, Grundy, and DuPage.
Still have questions?
No worries - we're here to help. Get the reassurance you need and contact us today.
© 2026 Hicks Insurance Group. All Rights Reserved.

Website Made By Aelieve Digital Marketing

Privacy Policy & Legal
Get Your Personal Insurance Quote
In need of anything from car insurance to rental insurance? We have you covered.
Get Your Commercial Insurance Quote
Ready to get started with your Commercial Insurance plan? You're in the right place.
Get Your Life
Insurance Quote
In need of anything from disability insurance to long-term care? We have you covered.
Get Your Personal Insurance Quote
In need of anything from car insurance to rental insurance? We have you covered.
Get Your Commercial Insurance Quote
Ready to get started with your Commercial Insurance plan? You're in the right place.
Get Your Life
Insurance Quote
In need of anything from disability insurance to long-term care? We have you covered.
Get Your Personal Insurance Quote
In need of anything from car insurance to rental insurance? We have you covered.
Get Your Commercial Insurance Quote
Ready to get started with your Commercial Insurance plan? You're in the right place.
Get Your Life
Insurance Quote
In need of anything from disability insurance to long-term care? We have you covered.
Get Your Personal Insurance Quote
In need of anything from car insurance to rental insurance? We have you covered.
Get Your Commercial Insurance Quote
Ready to get started with your Commercial Insurance plan? You're in the right place.
Get Your Life
Insurance Quote
In need of anything from disability insurance to long-term care? We have you covered.